Understanding Your Auto Insurance Claim: Tips from a Boise Body Shop

September 8, 2025

Dealing with auto insurance claims can be stressful, but knowing the process and having the right support can make it smoother. Here's what you need to know:

  • Understand Your Policy: Familiarize yourself with your coverage (collision, comprehensive, liability) and deductible to avoid surprises.
  • Idaho's At-Fault Insurance System: The at-fault driver covers damages. If you're less than 50% at fault, you can still recover compensation, but it will be reduced by your fault percentage.
  • After an Accident: Prioritize safety, document the scene, and exchange information. File your claim within 24 hours, providing all necessary details and evidence.
  • Choosing a Repair Shop: In Idaho, you can pick any shop, not just those recommended by your insurer. Experienced shops, like Franklin Auto Body, can handle claims, coordinate with insurers, and ensure quality repairs.
  • OEM Parts: To ensure your car's safety and value, request Original Equipment Manufacturer (OEM) parts in your repair estimate. Check your policy for coverage or be prepared to cover the cost difference.
  • Common Challenges: Low settlements or delays? Document everything, negotiate calmly, and escalate if needed. Partnering with a skilled repair shop can help resolve disputes and streamline the process.

Franklin Auto Body simplifies claims by managing paperwork, coordinating with insurers, and offering top-tier repair services. Their expertise ensures your car is repaired safely and efficiently, taking the stress out of the claims process.

Auto Insurance Claims Process: Not-At-Fault Accident

Auto Insurance Claims Basics in Idaho

Understanding Idaho's insurance laws can help you handle claims with confidence. In this state, financial responsibility for damages hinges on determining fault. Here's a closer look at how Idaho's rules influence the claims process.

Idaho's At-Fault Insurance System

Idaho uses an at-fault insurance system, meaning the driver responsible for causing an accident must cover the resulting damages. After an accident, insurers rely on various pieces of evidence - such as police reports, witness accounts, traffic citations, and on-scene details - to determine who was at fault. The at-fault driver’s liability insurance typically covers costs like vehicle repairs, medical bills, and other associated expenses. This system also allows you to seek compensation directly from the at-fault driver's insurance provider.

Modified Comparative Fault Rule

Idaho's modified comparative fault rule, outlined in Idaho Code § 6-801, introduces the "50% bar rule." This means if you're found to be 50% or more responsible for an accident, you can't recover any damages. However, if you're less than 50% at fault, you can still receive compensation - though your payout will be reduced in proportion to your share of the blame.

For example, if you're deemed 30% responsible for an accident with $10,000 in damages, your compensation would be reduced by 30%, leaving you with $7,000. This makes thorough documentation - like photos of the accident scene, witness information, and detailed police reports - essential to ensure fault is assigned accurately.

If you believe your share of fault is unfair, you have the option to dispute it. Presenting strong evidence with the help of experts can improve your chances of receiving fair compensation.

How to File an Auto Insurance Claim: Step-by-Step Guide

Filing an auto insurance claim doesn’t have to be overwhelming. Acting promptly and staying organized can make the process much smoother.

What to Do Right After an Accident

Your first priority should always be safety. If possible, move your vehicle to a safe spot, turn on your hazard lights, and check for injuries. If anyone is hurt or there’s major property damage, call 911 right away. Even for minor accidents, a police report can strengthen your claim.

While waiting for emergency responders, start documenting everything. Snap photos of all vehicles involved, focusing on the damage from different angles. Don’t stop there - capture the scene, including street signs, traffic signals, skid marks, and road conditions. Be sure to take pictures of license plates, insurance cards, and driver’s licenses for everyone involved.

Exchange contact information with all parties at the scene. This includes names, phone numbers, insurance details, policy numbers, and driver’s license numbers. If there are witnesses, get their names and contact information too. Witness statements can be critical if there’s any dispute about who’s at fault.

It’s important to avoid discussing fault or admitting responsibility, even if you think you might be to blame. Stick to factual statements about what happened. Determining fault is up to the insurance companies and, if necessary, the police.

How to Report the Accident to Your Insurance Company

Contact your insurance company within 24 hours of the accident. Most insurers offer 24/7 claim reporting through hotlines or mobile apps, making it easy to get started. Have your policy number, driver’s license, and all the details you gathered at the scene ready when you call.

Be prepared to provide specific details about the accident. This includes the exact time, date, and location, as well as a step-by-step account of what happened. Mention relevant factors like weather conditions, traffic patterns, or anything else that contributed to the incident, such as construction zones or malfunctioning traffic lights.

Submit all your documentation as soon as possible. This includes photos, the police report number, witness contact information, and any records of injuries. Many insurers let you upload these through their mobile apps or online portals, which can save time.

Your insurance company will assign a claims adjuster to handle your case. This person will guide you through the process. Make sure to note their name, phone number, and email address. Ask them about their preferred way to communicate and how long they typically take to respond.

Once you’ve reported the accident, keep all your documents organized to stay on top of your claim.

How to Track and Manage Your Claim

Keep everything related to your claim in one place. This includes your claim number, adjuster’s contact information, photos, receipts, repair estimates, and any correspondence. Also, log every phone call with the date, time, and details of the discussion.

Regular follow-ups are key. For complex claims, check in weekly; for simpler cases, every other week might be enough. Submit any requested documents as soon as possible - delays can slow down the process.

Understanding typical timelines can help you manage your expectations. Simple claims, where fault is clear and damage is minor, are often resolved in 1-2 weeks. More complicated cases involving injuries, disputed fault, or extensive damage can take weeks or even months. Your adjuster should give you an estimated timeline based on your situation.

Always get written confirmation for major decisions or agreements. For example, if your adjuster approves certain repairs or agrees to cover specific costs, ask for an email confirmation. This protects you in case there are personnel changes or disputes later on.

One common reason claims get delayed is missing deadlines for submitting requested documents. Set reminders to follow up if you don’t hear back within the timeframe your adjuster promised.

How to Choose the Right Repair Shop: Why Franklin Auto Body Works

Franklin Auto Body

Picking the right repair shop can make your insurance claim process smoother, saving you both time and money.

Your Right to Choose a Repair Shop

In Idaho, you have the freedom to choose the repair shop you trust, even if your insurance company suggests a preferred provider. While network shops might offer perks like direct billing, you’re not required to use them. As long as the shop you choose meets industry standards and provides fair estimates, your insurance company will typically honor your decision.

To make an informed choice, look for shops with proper certifications, strong reviews, and experience with your specific vehicle type. This ensures your car is in expert hands.

Franklin Auto Body's Skills and Services

Franklin Auto Body stands out with its I-CAR Gold Class certified technicians, capable of repairing all makes and models while adhering to top safety and quality standards.

Their services cover everything from collision repair and auto body painting to towing and glass replacement - all under one roof. This one-stop approach simplifies the repair process and coordination with insurance companies. Plus, their pre- and post-repair diagnostics catch hidden damage and confirm that all systems are functioning correctly after repairs.

This level of expertise ensures a smooth and reliable repair experience.

How Franklin Auto Body Makes Insurance Claims Easier

Franklin Auto Body takes the stress out of handling insurance claims. They work directly with all major insurance providers, managing communication with your adjuster so you don’t have to. They’ll even help arrange rental cars, clarifying coverage details and approved agencies to eliminate confusion.

Their precise, industry-standard estimates make negotiations with adjusters straightforward. On top of that, Franklin Auto Body offers deductible assistance and financing options to ease financial strain. With their towing services, your vehicle is safely transported, and they handle all the necessary insurance paperwork for you.

sbb-itb-8923c18

Getting Coverage for OEM Parts and Quality Repairs

After navigating the claims process, the next step is ensuring your vehicle gets quality repairs with OEM parts. These parts are essential for maintaining your car's safety, performance, and resale value. Knowing how to secure coverage for Original Equipment Manufacturer (OEM) parts starts with understanding your insurance policy and taking deliberate steps during the repair process.

Why OEM Parts Are Important

OEM parts are made by your car’s original manufacturer, ensuring they fit and perform just like the parts your vehicle was built with. They undergo strict testing to meet the manufacturer's standards, making them essential for maintaining safety and reliability. Plus, they help preserve your car's resale value. With these benefits in mind, it’s worth taking the necessary steps to ensure your repair estimate includes only OEM parts.

How to Secure OEM Parts in Your Repair Estimate

Standard auto insurance policies often don’t automatically cover OEM parts, especially for older vehicles. To improve your chances of getting OEM coverage, follow these steps:

  • Check your policy for an OEM endorsement or rider: If your policy doesn’t already include OEM coverage, reach out to your insurer to inquire about adding it. Alternatively, consider switching to a company that offers this option.
  • Communicate your preference early: Let your insurance adjuster and repair shop know upfront that you prefer OEM parts. Don’t assume they’ll be included automatically.
  • Ask specific questions: When speaking with your insurer, clarify what parts are covered, any restrictions, additional costs, and how OEM parts will be installed.
  • Choose a reputable repair shop: Opt for a body shop experienced in advocating for OEM parts. Shops with strong relationships with insurers and parts suppliers can often help make your case.
  • Carefully review the repair estimate: Before approving any work, ensure the estimate clearly specifies OEM parts. Look out for abbreviations like "A/M" (aftermarket) or "LKQ" (used parts), which indicate alternatives to OEM parts.

Handling Issues with Aftermarket Parts

Insurance companies often favor aftermarket parts because they’re cheaper, but these may not meet the same standards as OEM parts. If your insurer pushes for aftermarket parts, here’s what you can do to ensure quality repairs:

  • Understand your state’s insurance regulations: Some states mandate the use of OEM parts in specific situations, like repairs on newer vehicles. Researching local laws can give you leverage when negotiating with your insurer.
  • Prepare to cover the cost difference: If your policy doesn’t fully cover OEM parts, you might need to pay the difference out of pocket. While this adds to your expenses, it’s often worth it for the added safety, reliability, and retained value of your car.
  • Highlight safety and value: When discussing options with your insurance adjuster, emphasize that OEM parts are critical for maintaining your car’s safety systems and overall value. In some cases, manufacturers may offer OEM parts at competitive prices, which can support your argument.

If your insurer initially denies OEM coverage, don’t lose hope. Work closely with your repair shop to gather documentation explaining why OEM parts are necessary for your specific repair. An experienced body shop can often present technical arguments to strengthen your case and help you secure the coverage you need.

How to Handle Common Claims Problems

Dealing with auto insurance claims can sometimes feel like navigating a maze. Unexpected delays, low settlement offers, or other roadblocks from insurance companies can leave vehicle owners feeling frustrated. Knowing how to tackle these challenges head-on can make the process smoother and help you secure a fair settlement while keeping your repairs on track.

How to Negotiate with Insurance Adjusters

Insurance adjusters work for the insurance company, which means their priority is often to minimize payouts. While this doesn't mean they're out to get you, it does mean you'll need to advocate for yourself. Start by documenting everything - take photos of all damage, keep detailed records of conversations, and save every piece of paperwork related to your claim.

When speaking with adjusters, maintain a calm and professional demeanor. Present the facts clearly, and don't hesitate to ask for explanations if you receive a low estimate. Persistence is key - follow up regularly to ensure your case stays on their radar.

If there's a disagreement about the use of aftermarket parts, check your policy. In most cases, insurers are allowed to use these parts unless your policy includes an OEM (Original Equipment Manufacturer) endorsement.

What to Do About Delayed or Low Claim Settlements

Delayed claims can stem from a range of issues, such as overwhelmed adjusters or complex damage evaluations. If your claim is dragging on, reach out to your adjuster directly to request a status update and a timeline for resolution. Keep a written log of all communications, noting dates and key details.

When faced with a low settlement offer, don't feel pressured to accept the first number you're given. Insurance companies often start with conservative estimates, anticipating some negotiation. To counter this, get a second opinion from a reputable body shop. If their estimate is significantly higher, present this evidence to your adjuster, along with a detailed explanation of why the additional repairs are necessary.

If you're not making progress despite multiple attempts, escalate the issue within the insurance company. Request to speak with the adjuster's supervisor or file a formal complaint with their customer service department. Be sure to document all interactions, including names, dates, and outcomes.

For more serious disputes, reaching out to your state's insurance commissioner's office can be a game-changer. They have the authority to investigate complaints and can mediate disputes between policyholders and insurance companies, often leading to quicker resolutions.

Partnering with an experienced repair shop can also help streamline these challenges.

How Franklin Auto Body Supports Stress-Free Claims

A skilled body shop can make all the difference when navigating claims issues. Franklin Auto Body builds on these strategies to provide comprehensive support throughout the process. Their I-CAR GOLD CLASS certified technicians conduct thorough diagnostics to uncover all damage, including hidden issues that might not be immediately visible. This attention to detail helps avoid surprises later and ensures more accurate initial estimates.

Thanks to their expertise with insurance procedures, Franklin Auto Body knows how to present repair estimates in a way that adjusters can easily understand and approve. If disagreements arise over repair methods or parts, they can provide technical documentation to back up the necessary work.

Modern vehicles often come with complex electronic systems, and pre- and post-repair diagnostics are essential for identifying hidden damage to sensors, wiring, or computer modules. Franklin Auto Body's advanced diagnostics catch these issues early, reducing the risk of disputes down the line.

On top of that, the shop takes care of practical details, like coordinating vehicle inspections with insurance adjusters and helping you arrange a rental car while repairs are underway. By handling these administrative tasks, Franklin Auto Body makes the repair process less stressful and ensures everything moves along smoothly. Their expert services bring peace of mind during what can otherwise be a challenging experience.

Make Your Auto Insurance Claim Easier with Expert Help

Dealing with auto insurance claims can feel overwhelming, but having the right support makes all the difference. Franklin Auto Body simplifies the process by handling key details like coordinating with insurers and managing paperwork. This allows you to focus on getting back on the road instead of stressing over the fine print.

As mentioned earlier, having a well-thought-out repair plan is essential. The process starts with a detailed inspection to evaluate all visible and hidden damage, ensuring nothing is overlooked. With I-CAR GOLD CLASS certified technicians conducting in-depth diagnostics, potential issues are identified early. This not only ensures accurate cost estimates but also minimizes the risk of receiving a low settlement offer from your insurer.

Franklin Auto Body’s reputation speaks for itself. With a 4.8/5 rating from 203 reviews on Carwise.com, their commitment to quality and customer satisfaction is clear.

But Franklin Auto Body offers more than just repairs - they act as your advocate throughout the claims process. By choosing them, you’re not only ensuring top-notch repairs but also gaining a partner who knows the ins and outs of insurance procedures. They even take care of logistics like towing and arranging rental cars, making the entire experience smoother for Boise drivers. Their customer-focused approach truly sets them apart when it comes to navigating auto insurance claims.

FAQs

How does Idaho’s comparative fault rule impact my auto insurance claim after an accident?

Idaho operates under a modified comparative fault rule, which allows you to pursue compensation for damages as long as your share of fault in the accident is less than 50%. If you're deemed 50% or more at fault, you won’t be entitled to recover any damages.

For cases where your fault is determined to be less than 50%, your compensation will be adjusted according to your level of responsibility. For instance, if you're found to be 20% at fault, your compensation will be reduced by that same 20%. This rule plays a crucial role when filing an insurance claim after an accident in Idaho, so it's important to keep it in mind.

How can I make sure my insurance covers OEM parts for my car repairs?

To make sure your insurance covers OEM (Original Equipment Manufacturer) parts for vehicle repairs, start by thoroughly reviewing your policy. Look for any mention of OEM coverage or endorsements that specify the use of original manufacturer parts. If the details aren’t clear, reach out to your insurance provider for clarification.

When it’s time to file a claim, communicate your preference for OEM parts right away to both your insurer and the repair shop. Be specific about your expectations to avoid any confusion during the process. It’s also worth checking your state’s laws - some states require insurers to use OEM parts in certain scenarios, which could strengthen your case if needed.

By addressing these steps early, you can improve your chances of getting quality parts and ensuring your car is restored to factory standards.

What should I do if my insurance claim is delayed or I receive a low settlement offer?

If your insurance claim is taking longer than expected or you've been offered a settlement that feels too low, the first step is to reach out to your insurance company for a detailed explanation. Stay consistent and follow up regularly to keep your case on track.

Make sure to collect compelling evidence to strengthen your claim. This could include repair estimates, photos showing the extent of the damage, and any relevant paperwork. These details can give you more leverage during negotiations. If the delays persist or the settlement offers remain unsatisfactory, consider seeking help from a professional, like an insurance claims expert or attorney, who can advocate for you and work toward a fair outcome.